Rajasthan HC Jaipur

Section 12 Probation of Offenders Act: Rajasthan High Court reinstates compassionate appointee sacked over undisclosed conviction

Rajasthan High Court reinstated an appointee sacked over an undisclosed probation conviction, citing Section 12 of the Probation of Offenders Act.

pinkcitypost author img

October 11, 2026, 1:38 pm

Justice Anand Sharma

The bench of Justice Anand Sharma

Jaipur: The Rajasthan High Court has reinstated an electricity company’s compassionate appointee, sacked for not disclosing a conviction for which he was released on probation. The Court said probation protects a person from disqualification, so the non-disclosure could not have cost him the job.

Justice Anand Sharma held that the non-disclosure was not a material suppression, because disclosure could not have made him ineligible in law. The termination also violated natural justice, he said.

The Court observed: “Where disclosure of the fact could not, by operation of law, have resulted in denial of the benefit sought, non-disclosure of such fact cannot mechanically be elevated to the status of fraud, concealment or suppression warranting the extreme consequence of termination from service.”

The man’s father, an employee of Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited, died in service in 2014. The company appointed the son as a Helper-II probationer trainee on compassionate grounds in 2015.

Later, a police verification report showed a 2013 case under the Rajasthan Excise Act, in which he was convicted but released on probation. His affidavit at the time of appointment had said there was no pending case and no conviction.

The company ended his services in 2016, saying his character and antecedents were unsatisfactory under a condition of the appointment order.

The petitioner argued that he was a minor when the case was registered, when it was decided and when he gave the affidavit. He said Section 12 of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 removes any disqualification arising from such a conviction.

The company said a person seeking public employment must come with clean hands and that he had filed a false affidavit.

Justice Sharma first found that the notice for a personal hearing was vague. It did not tell him that he had to explain the alleged suppression. The Court said a hearing must be “real and effective and not a mere formality”.

Second, the Court held that a conviction followed by probation under Section 4 carries no disqualification. It relied on Section 12 and on a Jodhpur bench ruling in Mohammed Aslam Silawat v State of Rajasthan.

Depriving a person of appointment would defeat the Act’s purpose of rehabilitation, the Court said.

Third, even if he had disclosed the conviction, he could not have been disqualified. The Court said “the essential element of material suppression” was “conspicuously absent”.

The Court applied the Supreme Court’s ruling in Avtar Singh v Union of India. It says an employer must weigh the nature of the offence, the post and the circumstances before acting on suppression. The decision cannot be mechanical.

It distinguished the ruling the company relied on, which involved a police constable with several other FIRs. Suppression, the Court said, is neither automatically condoned nor automatically fatal.

The Court quashed the termination and directed the company to reinstate him forthwith, with continuity of service and consequential service benefits. He gets notional benefit for the period from termination to the judgment, and actual benefit from the date of the judgment.

Case Details
Title
Vikram Singh v State of Rajasthan and Others
Case No.
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1607/2017
Counsel for petitioner
Saurabh Purohit (for Rakesh Kumar)
Counsel for respondent
Priya Rastogi (for Ankur Rastogi)
First published: October 11, 2026
Click on the following link(s) to find the latest & related stories on: > >
Chat with us