Rajasthan High Court suspends five-year sentence in culpable homicide case, finds private defence plea arguable
Rajasthan High Court suspends the five-year sentences of three men pending appeal, holding their private defence plea raises arguable questions.
Published:

The bench of Justice Farjand Ali
Jodhpur: The Rajasthan High Court has suspended the five-year sentences of three men convicted of culpable homicide, until their appeal is decided. It said their plea of private defence raised arguable questions.
Justice Farjand Ali allowed the application of Monu Mohammed, Arif Mohammed and Munshi Mohammed, who are lodged in Nagaur District Jail. The Additional Sessions Judge, Jayal, convicted them on Aug 18, 2026, and sentenced them to five years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 10,000.
The applicants said the trial court had wrongly assessed the facts and the law. They pointed out that they stayed on bail during the trial without misusing their liberty, and that their appeal would take time. The Public Prosecutor opposed the plea.
The Court explained that bail before conviction and suspension of sentence after conviction are different. At the second stage, the appeal court must see whether the grounds disclose a substantial and arguable case. It need not record conclusive findings on the merits.
The Court said:
“If the material on record suggests that the findings of the trial court may be debatable, the discretion under Section 389 CrPC … can be justifiably invoked.”
It relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Muna Bisoi v State of Odisha, decided on Feb 16, 2026. That ruling held that long pendency of a criminal appeal, not caused by the convict, is a valid ground to suspend a sentence. The High Court noted that it has a large number of pending criminal appeals and early disposal is uncertain. Even if the conviction is upheld, the offence or the sentence may be reconsidered at the appeal stage, it said.
Counsel for the applicants argued that they had acted in private defence and that the force used was wrongly treated as excessive. The Court said the test is not whether a less harmful way of resisting was possible on calm reflection. It is whether the force can reasonably be judged in the setting of the danger as it appeared to the person facing it. Citing Bishna v State of West Bengal, it observed:
“A person suddenly exposed to an assault, apprehending death or grievous bodily injury, cannot be expected to weigh the precise degree of force necessary to repel the attack with mathematical accuracy.”
The Court added that private defence is protective, not punitive or retaliatory, and does not allow harm beyond what is reasonably necessary.
It said several points needed careful reappraisal in the appeal. These were how the incident began, the rival versions of who started the assault, the injuries on each side and the role of each applicant. They were arguable questions that could not be shut out at this stage.
The sentences stay suspended until the appeal is finally decided. The applicants were released on a personal bond of Rs 50,000 with two sureties of Rs 25,000 each. They must appear before the trial court every January until the appeal is decided and report any change of address.






