Rajasthan High Court sets aside 24 Insurance Ombudsman awards for ignoring alleged non-disclosure by exporter
The Rajasthan High Court quashed 24 Insurance Ombudsman awards, saying alleged non-disclosure of parcel arrival dates was not examined, and remanded them.
Published:

The bench of Justice Anand Sharma
Jaipur: The Rajasthan High Court has quashed 24 awards of the Insurance Ombudsman and sent the complaints back for a fresh decision. The Ombudsman never examined whether cover was taken after the parcels had already reached the United States.
Justice Anand Sharma said the Ombudsman acted on incomplete facts and, in the Court’s words, “failed to examine a circumstance which goes to the very root of the insured risk.”
The insured is a Jaipur exporter of silver jewellery. She held an open cover marine cargo policy from Oriental Insurance Company Limited. She posted 24 consignments to New York by registered post, but they were not delivered. The insurer rejected her claims, and the Ombudsman allowed them with deductions and interest.
The insurer told the Court that the individual insurance certificates were issued after the parcels had reached the US Import Office. In the lead case, the parcel was sent on May 18, 2022 and reached the US Import Office on May 21. The certificate was issued on May 27.
It said it did not know the arrival dates when it rejected the claims, because the exporter did not supply them despite repeated requests. It put the dates together only after the awards were passed.
The exporter argued that this was a new ground raised for the first time in the High Court. She said the rejection letters did not mention it. She also said the open cover was a standing contract, and declarations could be made within its period.
The Court did not accept that objection in full. It noted that the exporter herself disclosed the arrival dates in her complaints before the Ombudsman, so no new fact had been brought in. The Court said:
“…this Court cannot deny to entertain such plea, merely because the precise legal formulation was not adopted before the subordinate authority.”
The Court then turned to Sections 19 and 20 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963. Insurance rests on utmost good faith, and the insured must disclose material facts. A fact is material if it would influence a prudent insurer in taking the risk or fixing the premium.
The Court kept in mind the limits of its supervisory power under Article 227 of the Constitution, citing Shalini Shyam Shetty v Rajendra Shankar Patil. But it said that where a material circumstance on record has not been considered, the proper course is to send the matter back. It should not decide the facts itself.
The Court made clear that it has not found that the exporter suppressed any fact. Nor did it hold that the certificates were invalid or that the insurer was free of liability. Those questions are left to the Ombudsman.
The Ombudsman must hear both sides again and decide, preferably within four months. The insurer’s deposit of the awarded amount with the Registrar General will not be released to either side until that fresh decision. The parties are to appear before the Ombudsman on Nov 2, 2026, or on the date the Ombudsman fixes.





